Brilliant book, really enjoyed this.

A wonderful book which discusses the actions and consequences of the battles against today’s societal norms. I really enjoyed the stories that gave a background to the protagonists. Really great stuff.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful

Compelling and Historically Portentous

I expected a lot from the title alone and got far more than I could have wished for. Yes a most compelling audiobook, well written and narrated; Last Stands delivers the details of several key historical events involving individual or group efforts to stave off defeat knowing that the outcome will result in death to the defenders. Touching on the Spartan (possibly the most famous last stand beyond Custer's at the Little Big Horn) defence at Thermopylae to Korea in 1950's, this is a revisionist look at histories heroic but necessary human battles against all odds. Each topic is usually conjoined by another similar event at a later time period; but the emphasis is not on purely comparison but the similarity of the futility based upon a situation that despite changes in human development over centuries; the same outcome is inevitable. What is also evident from the book is that it highlights the modern conundrum of how history not only repeats itself; but that the causes, effects, and post event consequences directly or indirectly linked have not changed. Listen and learn about the past to understand the present is perhaps the best way to describe this book.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful

Compelling

An informative and solid book with the curious omission of Dien Bien Phu . Unless l missed it .

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

title is misleading

I was hoping to get more info on the psyche of the people involved. However this is not the case.
The subject is made very wide. A lot of personal conclusions and half truths. In one case he states that the nazi persecuted Catholics. totally wrong since he had corporation from the pope in those days. Priest where recruiting people to fight communism.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Bigoted views of the world. Very poor

I think people should be warned on the extremely distasteful views of the author’s view. At times it very distasteful. Be warned

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

why men fight

the topic is interesting and the idea to go through historical samples is good. Premises were promising.
Unfortunately narration is weak.
- Historically very superficial, not even acceptable at my high school level; it would have been better to eliminate it, since the book is not a history text
- psychological analysis is weak
- no real conclusions

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

More Ripping Yarns than Why Men Fight

I bought the book because of it’s title ‘Why men fight when all is lost’. On this score it disappointed. It is a collection of ‘Ripping Yarns’ or to be more accurate, stories and histories around the last stands and the main protagonists involved. Possibly the most interesting and self indulgent was when he wrote about his Father. If you like a collection of incomplete histories of a few battles then this is for you but please don’t expect a psychological analysis of why men fight using the last stands listed as examples. It simply doesn’t do what it says on the cover. A very misleading title.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!