Good for mountaineers

One Day as a Tiger By John Porter and narrated by Stewart Crank is a medley of genres encompassing mountaineering history and culture focussed through the life of Alex MacIntyre.

Stewart Crank is well enunciated, with good cadence and emphasis. There is a subtle use of accents to discern between various speakers, however it can be difficult to follow quotes and discern different speakers at times. There is a sentence roughly half way through in chapter 22 where the narrator makes a mistake on the word 'twang', and has to restart the sentence. I'm.assuming this was meant to be edited out but was forgotten/missed.

From the outset there is drama and a sense of 'old-school' and changed times. Straight into the action, One Day as a Tiger is not really something you can sit and listen to in the background - it deserves and requires atyention, and keeps you hooked with both smiles and laughter, but also with hints of the darker sides of life, that makes you stop and think, and appreciate it all just that little bit more.

With some very visual descriptions, it is best if the listener has some knowledge and understanding of the basics of climbing and mountaineering, otherwise some enthusiasm may be lost through the use of specific terms and assumptions of knowledge. But for those with an interest in recent mountaineering history, One Day as a Tiger can really be a fascinating listen.

The quote on Macintyre's tomb (the first line of which is the title of the book) is fitting, and definitely makes you think. Discussion around his death and his vision and passion for life is fascinating, heartfelt and rather emotional. Macintyre's predictions were uncanny and ultimately true. He really seemed a young man ahead of his time, and it becomes clear why this book celebrates his short life, whilst also paying homage to some of the other incredible mountaineers and their exceptional achievements over the years.

The description of Macintyre and his life and outlook is very respectable, and something of a motivator to change and better oneself too. The readings of Macintyre's articles give an idea of just how articulate and reflective he was as an individual, and help put context to the comments regarding his life and the other various accomplishments in mountaineering history referred to here.

With interesting and informative discussion around Bonnington and large expeditions, along with the BMC, policies and education, and even relationships, definitely a good listen to learn about the foundations of light and fast alpinism.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful

Dreadful

I really dislike this book and wish I had not bought it. It’s so self satisfied as if being a pub bore in the 70s was the height of aspiration. I don’t know how it turns out because I’m so bored I’ve given up- abs I read a LOT of climbing/ mountaineering books. Do yourself a favour and don’t buy this.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Stilted awkward delivery

Cant decide if its the barrator or writer that is spoiling what should be a good story. The narrator certainly isn’t doing it any favours , but the dragging out of irrelevant opinion snd historical asides isnt helping. Im on chapter 4 and know almost bugger all about McIntyre or his climbing escapades, and rapidly losing the will to carry on.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!