Tremendous

So enjoyable. Well written, interesting and so full of wondrous life experiences. Narration is excellent.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Beautiful

I read ( listened) to this after Bodies of ligh and loved the continuation of the characters. I feel sad that I can't know anymore about Ally et al. Wonderful narration too. Thanks!

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Great sequel to a great book

Would you recommend this audiobook to a friend? If so, why?

I love the depth of the characters and their personal journeys. Ally continues to make her way in the world as one of the first female doctors in the UK and focusing on an underdeveloped aspect of medical science: the treatment of psychiatric patients. And her personal life has changed a lot compared to the last book and keeps changing throughout this one.

What was one of the most memorable moments of Signs for Lost Children?

When Ally's visit to Manchester comes to an end. Also, Tom's journey through Japan was incredible.

What about Merield Scholfield’s performance did you like?

It was completely unobtrusive. And by that, I don't mean that it wasn't memorable. Even a great narrator can sometimes make me feel that they're obstructing the flow of the story, but not her. I thoroughly enjoyed her style.

Did you have an emotional reaction to this book? Did it make you laugh or cry?

Yes, I did. It made me cry a couple of times. It moved me deeply and it was one of those books leaves me thinking about it even when I'm already halfway through the next one. The personal journeys the characters go through and their emotions are so well described, that at times I felt what they were feeling. And I find some of the things they go through so relatable! I've been through a couple of those situations and I couldn't believe the author's ability to capture the emotions and thought they provoked.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Exploration of doors and chambers of heart & mind

Signs of Lost Children follows on from Moss's Bodies of Light, but is also stand-alone. It's an immensely sophisticated, interesting and different novel. It's such an intelligent and earnest work that it seems mean not to give it straight 5s, but it does have some imperfections.

Set in the 1880s, Ally and Tom are separated by their work just weeks after their marriage. Tom travels to Japan to build lighthouses and Ally, a qualified doctor, begins work at Truro asylum. Immediately we know this is no ordinary nineteenth century couple, and this is no ordinary novel! The main body of the story is taken up alternating between Tom in Japan and Ally in England, but I found the best part was very much towards the end when they come together again after 6 months and their apartness is almost impossible to bridge. The very end is the only glimmer of what you might expect from a nineteenth century novel...
Moss is a beautiful writer, as sensitive and delicate when describing the filigree of leaves in a Japanese garden, the fineness of Japanese embroideries; the indignities of female inmates of the madhouse, the wildness of the Cornish coast, and most of all, the intricacies of the heart and mind. The whole is sympathetically and pleasantly narrated with sensible pauses between the Japanese and English sections which give you just the required moment to make the adjustment.

The elements which made me slightly disappointed overall was the way that Tom's very interesting experiences with the Japanese culture and his lighthouse work was shadowy in comparison with the detail in Ally's life, as the indelible corrosive effects of her mother's harsh morality and carping cause her to suffer a breakdown and she struggles to find acceptance as a doctor working amongst insane women. The whole work is massively and scrupulously researched and a whole raft of issues and their ramifications - from mental instability to the legacy of childhood on adulthood and the struggle for identity - are explored. This is always interesting but sometimes the intellectual freight becomes too heavy as ideas become stronger than the characters.

Moss's novels are gathering critical acclaim fast and I will certainly download her newest novel The Tidal Zone.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

4 people found this helpful

Unrelenting misery!

A well researched and well written story but a test of endurance! There is a flicker of hope in the epilogue but the rest is really miserable. It left me feeling completely depressed and reluctant to attempt anything else by this author.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful

One of the best books I’ve ever read

Absolutely brilliant book, wonderfully told by Sarah Moss and beautifully read by Merield Scholfield. I think Ally is one of my favourite ever characters in literature.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

2 people found this helpful