Gripped from the start!

This was an absolutely gripping story. It was brilliantly written and narrated. I was sad to finish it because now I miss the characters who were part of my life for a few days; that's always the sign of a good book!

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Fantastic

I really enjoyed this book it was extremely well written & also well read. My book of the year so far
Quite touching and graphic

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful

Abattoir of dreams

I’m so glad I read The liars promise first otherwise I would have given up on this book. Usually I love David Thorpe the narrator but the voice of carver sounded like Roy slater from only fools and horses and totally irritating. The liars promise was a free book which I loved, when reading the reviews everyone said they read this one first which they loved personally not nearly as good as the other one

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

You must listen to this book!

This is not your usual crime thriller. But that’s a good thing. It is about a very difficult subject, that of institutional physical and sexual abuse of children and young people. It’s about domestic abuse, murder, cruelty and collusion. At times it is difficult to listen to. It is heartbreaking, brutally honest, visceral and unflinchingly real. But it’s such an important story and subject matter. It is told from the perspective of the abused children in such a believable and authentic way it is utterly compelling and you cannot stop listening. The narrator does an absolutely amazing job. Each of the many characters even the ones with smaller roles have distinct voices which is a great skill and brings the story to life in all its technicolour horror. However, it isn’t a relentless tale of misery. It is a story about love, and friendship, brotherhood, the kindness of strangers and most of all it’s the story of hope. When all is lost and unbelievably awful, there is still love to be found. I was deeply moved by this book. It will echo in my head for a long time. Mark Tilbury has a gift. I cannot wait to listen to and read his other novels. If you want to listen to something that challenges you, that forces you to face the uglier side of life, that takes you on an emotional rollercoaster but is also beautifully sensitive, achingly so, I urge you to purchase this book. Not many books leave their mark on you, this one certainly has. Thank you Mark Tilbury - I salute you!

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful

Okay I suppose

It’s got a beginning middle and an end but it’s not the best I’ve listened too. Was expecting something different after reading the glowing reviews.

No super duper twists and it does have some quite detailed descriptions of child abuse but I’ve heard worse.

It’s well narrated.. maybe I chose the wrong book to start my journey with this author.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Wow! Gripped from the beginning to end

What can I say?
Narration - always good from David Thorpe. He can’t “do” accents and voices like some but his simplicity works so well with the books I’ve listened to and their characters.
Now for the book / Audio.
Recommend on UK Crime Books Facebook page. SO glad I’d seen the post and picked this out.
It starts - present day and works backwards and forwards weaving a soul destroying story of abuse. Mental and physical and all the bits in between some parts I found very difficult to listen to. David Thorpe had worked his magic with the words until the characters were like family. A very strange feeling to want to look out for a character!! The rest was a delicate love story. The warmth and care the main characters shared despite the horrors was beautiful.
It’s been a long time since a book has had met this engrossed.
Clever writing and narration brought the book to life and the characters eternal presence.

I will definitely look for Mark Tilbury again. I do hope I like the narrator on his next book. That’s the only problem when authors don’t keep the same narrators it can be hard to follow.

This book I will most certainly listen to again. Out of 200 plus books in my Audible collection there are only 4 to date I’ve revisited.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!