repetitive and slightly frustrating

this is a book that situated the Talmud. it situated it, explaining its importance in Judaism and how and why it came into being. however, it is very general as a rule. it will tell you the types of things covered, the types of people who covered them, and the status of conclusions(definitive/vinding(. however it is quite frustratingly repetitive. an example by be alluding to the 'methods' used by groups of scholars to examine texts and ideas. it may be one group of scholars have different methods. however we don't learn even the rudiments of what these methods were/are, or how they differe.
we learn the Talmud is formed by debate abd understanding requires continuing that debate actively. but we never really get a worked example to understand what this means in practice. the closest we get are some examples of quirky conclusions which seem odd standing alone.
this generality helps initially in getting a broad sense of Subject matter. however it gets increasingly repetitious and sadly ultimately tedious, and overall that means this introduction can't really be judged a success.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Mistakes in recording.

There are several mistakes in the recording, where the narration suddenly stops and picks up in a different place.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful