Man's unimaginable inhumanity to man

In the scrupulous research of her Tyrolean father's life , Meriel Schindler has produced a very personal and detailed account of Jewish life in Innsbruck in the 1930s and beyond before and after the targeting and annihilation of Jews by German forces. It is of course a fearful story but the Austrian angle is less common and more interesting to read about.

The author's father Kurt (whose testimony she knows cannot be relied on given his false stories) kept the Cafe Schindler in Innsbruck, an almost magical place where people gathered for schnapps, debate, jazz and a sumptuous array of cream cakes - until it was stolen from him by the Nazis and the family eventually lost everything.. The author's descriptions of Kristallnacht are heartbreakingly terrible as is the whole catalogue of indelible cruelties and killings meted out to the Jewish people in those years of crazed destruction.

As well as all this, the author also debates the reliability and unreliability of memory and whether there can be such a thing as truth.; also insight into the experiences of displaced people, and the consequences of deep trauma.

The book comes from conscientious research into which the driven author has clearly poured all her heart as well as her legal training. It seems almost ungrateful to say that it's over-long, but some of the detail (particularly the painstaking years of post -war restoration battles by the family} could have been pruned to advantage.

The narration is extremely competent and sensitive and her German is perfect, but her intonation is rather curious and with such a long book - 14 hours - for me it became irritating.

This is an admirable and moving tribute to the author's family,

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

An amazing story, about history, family, war.

This was such a delight to listen to. An investigative story into a family's secrets, especially those of a father. It's full of astounding connections, and revelations, peeling back layers of history I wasn't even aware existed: about Austria, Italy, the Tyrol. And so wonderfully read by Kristin Atherton, who does such a fine job of telling this fascinating tale while delivering excellent Germanic pronunciations, well to my ears at least. If you thought you knew a lot about the first and second world wars, read this book, and be surprised at the intriguing gems that you will uncover. This is a wonderful book.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Exceptional story beautifully told

The best book I have listened too. Not sure what to do now it is finished.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

3 people found this helpful

Lost memories come to life.

A brilliant bitter-sweet telling of a family history, gently pulling together a group of characters from pre-war Bohemia, Vienna and the Tyrol. The careful historical research is easily digestible, illuminating the fascinating diverse characters who establish a family business in Linz and Innsbruck.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful

Absolutely fascinating!

This story, about the family Schindler, is fascinating. The detail is both humorous and harrowing. Lovingly told from the perspective of a daughter who doesn’t know what to make of her beloved/infuriating father’s lies, her research takes her back to the very beginning of the Cafe Schindler in Innsbruck. It is exquisitely read by Kristin Atherton, who ‘became’ Meriel in my head. I cannot recommend this enough.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

BEST BOOK OF 2021

A wonderful story !! I felt I was part of the Schindler family and Innsbruck. The book will stay with me forever.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!