A beautiful study of depression, love & acceptance

Mimi Matthews really is an incredibly talented writer. Something I love so much about her is her uncanny ability to capture the plight of women in the past, but also the potential for women—even in times gone by—to find fulfillment and happiness in their lives, and to self-actualize. I was reluctant about Fair as a Star because I knew it dealt with depression and didn’t want to be overly bogged down by what people with depression had to endure, and still endure. I also didn’t know how something as intense or fraught with difficulty as “acute melancholia,” an unfitting betrothal, and a strong case of forbidden longing could be resolved in a few hours. Somehow it is not rushed, is beautifully presented as a story of understanding and hope and ties a touching love story into the bargain. Alex Wyndham is, of course, perfect. I don’t doubt we will get more Matthews/Wyndham collabs as her future books come out—either way this very quick listen is still work the credit. Very possibly, it might eclipse some of her other work it is so gently wonderful.


Ps. In the, likely fruitless, hope that Mimi Matthews reads reviews: you are so adept at the Victorian world and writing historical fiction. You are a committed, highly competent researcher and storyteller. But your gift shouldn’t be confined to this period alone! You should try your hand at other points in history like... maybe... perhaps... 17th century Britain might tickle you? Because it is a very turbulent and interesting time religiously, politically, and for especially for women.... and I feel like you could explore womanhood in this period with such aplomb. Just a thought, either way you have my loyalty!

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful

Mimi Matthews and Alex Wyndham is the perfect combination!

The story is that Mimi Matthew crafts are the kind that you can get lost combined. That was the sultry voice of Alex Wyndham and you have a winning combination. This is the ultimate story escape for me. I enjoyed every moment and I can highly recommend it for those who like a clean romance.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

The perfect narrator

This is a beautiful story of a woman with depression (melancholy). In Victorian times, there was no understanding of depression. It was felt that, since it didn’t make sense, that it showed a lack of character and self control. Beryl is engaged to the Squire, a decent but unimaginative man. Mark, the Squire’s younger brother and the curate is in love with Beryl. An enjoyable tale set in a charming small town.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!