A Classic indeed

This is not a book I had a huge urge to listen to for a long time, so it’s not been on my to do list. But I am glad I did, the performance from Annette Bening is pitch perfect, and the style of the book is very interesting, especially given the time in which it was written. I’m sure I would not have fitted in to the Dalloway’s social circle in the slightest, but the book is a pretty damming account of the upper class between the wars.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Wonderful novel, mismatch on the reader

Such an important insightful novel in so many ways— the groundbreaking interior monologues and the subtle, beautiful flow from character to character, the interiority, the mistaken assumptions, the disconnects, the wash of language. But not the best reader, a bit odd to hear such a very British novel in an American voice that mispronounces places and words sometimes though she gets the dreamlike, hypnotic flow. Still: very much enjoyed this

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Compelling English novel with US twist

Where does Mrs. Dalloway rank among all the audiobooks you’ve listened to so far?

Have not listened to many so it is impossible to say.

Who was your favorite character and why?

Mrs Dalloway herself. The world she inhabits bounces off and on her and we get a picture of a particular English class of Woolf's time.

How could the performance have been better?

An English narrator who can correctly pronounce Westminster, Piccadilly, Marylebone and say 'hawk', not 'hock'.

Was this a book you wanted to listen to all in one sitting?

It needs to be savoured I think. In any case Bening's habit of noisily taking an inbreath drove me to distraction. I could only take her in relatively small doses.

Any additional comments?

I expect US listeners will be perfectly happy with this. English English folk should listen to the sample carefully first.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

8 people found this helpful

'Oh! In the middle of my party, here's death.'

This quotation encapsulates this book for me. In this novel, which describes a single day in post-First World War England, the sense of the war having driven an enormous spike through the heart of the British Empire and English high society is palpable.

From the lady-about-town titular character to the badly shellshocked veteran Septimus Smith, the shadow of the recent conflict is felt deeply. The contrast of these two characters is a stark one; Septimus' mind is almost completely fractured by his experiences and he is suffering from extreme hallucinations (which are most vivid thanks to Woolf's stream-of-consciousness style allowing the reader to look inside Smith's mind) which have robbed his life of all meaning, whereas Mrs. Dalloway is merely planning a party, to take place that evening. Still, her every train of thought seems to end up at an unwanted dark station, showing that she too is haunted in her own way.

Many of the characters in this powerful tale are mourning the promise of their youth, which took place in a more innocent, less bloodstained world. There is a sense that, as much as they may try to go back to how things were before the war, the world has been irrevocably fractured. This feeling is heightened even more than Woolf can have intended by the modern reader's knowledge that the world was about to tumble into chaos once more with the coming of World War II, less than twenty years from the day presented in the novel.

'Mrs. Dalloway' was my first Woolf novel and I'm now kicking myself for not reading her work sooner. Themes and plot aside, this book contains some of the most poetic, lyrical and almost musical prose I've ever read. It really is a joy to read, which probably explains why I've practically inhaled this book; devouring it in just three sittings. I've just bought another of her books ('To The Lighthouse') so I can go back to Woolf-world again soon.

Annette Bening's performance is as fantastic as you would expect from an actor of her calibre. She really brings Woolf's writing to life and adds another dimension to the novel. Highly recommended.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

4 people found this helpful

A book for writers and aficionados of literature

This work describes a period and a class of people, the characters live deep in their cultural bubble and have no other perspective, the plot is a thread that appears and disappears at the whim of the writer. the characters relations are not all apparent unless you know from having read about it and even after knowing to me they appear so esoteric they added very little to the book.

The writing is brilliant and closer to a modern style but still fool of mannerisms that make you feel that this should have been a poem because it is so concentrated in feeling and form.

Is it worth reading? yes if only for Septimus and his passages, he moved me because he could not feel after surviving the great war and knew he was lost in fear and beauty, for me he is the heart of the book the only person that was outside the frivolity of everyday life. he is the masterpiece, all others are just the drone of repetition.

NOW about the narrator: I did not feel she was hard to understand or that she joined sentence, she was clear and well delivered. Some said they will get the book and read it, they will find that the cadence and length of the paragraphs will not change but of course they will have the pleasure of rereading the passage till it satisfies them and for those that need an English person reading it; what accent would you like her to have and how acted does this need to be?

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

3 people found this helpful

Extremely disappointed

Having never read any Virgina Woolf novels I forced myself to listen to the entire thing but it was a struggle. Was expecting so much more from such a famous writer. I get that her descriptions of the characters and their thoughts is deep and supposedly thought provoking, especially about society at that time, but there is no storyline at all.
So just to warn you… if you like a storyline to keep you interested, there is none.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful

Wrong voice for text

Might as well read Anne Tyler with an Oxford accent. Voice should be matched to text.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

3 people found this helpful

not for fans of English classical literature

Hated the way it was read. No concept of how it should have been read emphasis on the wrong words, pauses in the wrong places. absolutely dreadful. Avoid and pick the one read by Kristen Scott Thomas - delightful. I can now listen to the book instead of fuming about the narration.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful

Poorly narrated

I really struggled with this audiobook. I admit I have never read the paper copy but the narration was incredibly poor which made it almost impossible to follow. The sentences are disjointed and I couldn't tell when one sentence ended and another began. Very disappointing

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

10 people found this helpful

Sending it, back

I begin by confessing that only two stars for the story because I will buy the paper version of this novel in order to complete it. This is only the second audio book that I am returning. My review is not of the writing or the story.

The narration is, disjointed? and the intonation is such that you find, yourself working out how the sentence you have just listened. To was written. So many sentences with the last word attached to the beginning of the. Next that it becomes a translation. Exercise.

At 1 Hour and 58 minutes I shouted at it. Don't shoot the messenger. That was the point at which I realised that it has to go back.

Unusually, I do not recommend this audiobook. I hereby pledge to all the Woolf fans out there that I will honour the author by reading it.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

16 people found this helpful